Our Tester Says:
These are the most affordable pair, that's for sure. So if you want to try out the technology, these are a safe bet. The mesh pouch is nice, but the actual boxer fabric doesn't have enough stretch and the fit is a little long in the legs. And while the thicker waistband is comfortable, the screaming HANES logo is a little loud.
Comfort Flex Fit boxer briefs, $17.79 (for 3-pack) by Hanes
Our Tester Says:
Turns out, three Valet. writers already owned a pair. I wasn't one but I can now see why. These are the most discreet—their “BallPark Pouch” features barely-there lightweight mesh panels that don't cramp or push out your package. They simply separate your balls from your thighs. That, paired with the form-fitting cut allows freedom of movement and makes your butt look good. I really can't ask for more.
Our Tester Says:
These have “dual pouch technology,” which means everything gets its own space. I get what they're trying to do, and if you usually have to readjust yourself when wearing regular underwear, maybe you'll find it useful. But these were a little too involved for me. To be honest, it felt like my dick was sheathed in a tube sock and it was ... distracting. Plus, it wasn't exactly a flattering look for the package—I won't be wearing these on any dates.
Fast-Dry boxer briefs, $29.99 (for 2-pack) by Separatec
Sheath
Our Tester Says:
This can only be described as a push-up bra for your package. There's engineering here and while I don't think I'd wear them daily, I have to say I didn't hate the experience. The 3.21 Fly Series is the brand's flagship model and the stretchy, lightweight trunks are designed to isolate everything. There's a circular-seamed hole for your penis, to separate it from your testicles, which are separated from your thighs. But I found you don't always have to use the hole. Of course, on extremely hot days (or when I want my package to be a bit more pronounced) it could come in handy.
3.21 boxer briefs,
$27 by Sheath
Our Tester Says:
For guys that are maybe a bit more well-endowed, this pair offers plenty of space to keep everything contained and supported. The U-shaped pouch wraps under your package for a slight lift to keep your balls in place. The fabric is silky but substantial and withstood a lot of washings because I kept going back to this one pair. These cost more than I usually spend, but I'll be buying additional pairs.
Classic trunk,
$30 by BN3TH
Our Tester Says:
These have a smaller opening for the pouch, but I liked that it didn't just separate, it actually supports you. Like a sports bra for your junk. I didn't use the horizontal fly, but I did appreciate the mesh panels and moisture-wicking properties during workouts.
Paradise Pocket Athletic Fit boxer briefs, $18 by All Citizens